Rugby League Project Forums

General Category => Feedback/Suggestions => Topic started by: Ted Baxter on 15 June, 2026, 01:22:59 AM

Title: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: Ted Baxter on 15 June, 2026, 01:22:59 AM
https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/seasons/nsw-cup-2026/round-14/canterbury-bulldogs-reserves-vs-parramatta-eels-reserves/summary.html

Scrums: Parramatta 2-1

CB: Dykes played at 5/8 & Cochrane FB.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: GregRLP on 15 June, 2026, 04:42:31 PM
The NSWRL & Bulldogs website show Dykes at FB & Cochrane 5/8 the match report refers to Dykes as both FB & 5/8 and I can't find video of the game, what's your source.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: Ted Baxter on 16 June, 2026, 04:37:57 PM
The game was shown on Fox Sports prior to the first grade game. I now have a copy of it. To my knowledge, Taye Cochrane has only played fullback & Kade Dykes can play in a number of positions. It was stated during the opening of the game & in general play it was obvious.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: AJ Lucantonio on 16 June, 2026, 07:20:53 PM
Will confirm Ted's assessment. But, I will say it's been regular practice to leave as per the team-sheet that is submitted to the NSWRL/QRL/NRL.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: Ted Baxter on 17 June, 2026, 07:34:09 PM
Honest question; is this from say NRL time onwards? The reason I ask is that there have been plenty of changes in 80s games & there was a time when Brian Smith used to name a team & then make 5 or 6 positional changes to try & fool the opposition. He did this regularly.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: AJ Lucantonio on 17 June, 2026, 08:00:03 PM
As far as I'm concerned it's fairly general practice to go through the teamlist as chosen or displayed on the graphics at a televised match.
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: GregRLP on 17 June, 2026, 11:47:32 PM
It's a fairly common going way back to 1908 that players would change positions mid game or a replacement would come on and require positional changes or players would swap positions continually throughout a game I know Manly had been doing that with Kola & Faulalo in some games recently.

I feel we can only go off the latest team list as published at the time when the players take the field. So in this case it appears the team list was never changed Dykes was listed at fullback and Cochrane 5/8 if that's not how they played then we can only go by what is documented
Title: Re: NSW Cup Round 14 Canterbury V Parramatta
Post by: Ted Baxter on 23 June, 2026, 03:36:28 AM
A perfect example of why it should revert to the changes happened on the weekend. The Canterbury V Manly game where Burton & Crichton were switched. The game will have it noted in all reports that Crichton played 5/8, but the lists here & on nrl.com will be incorrect, although Fox Sports will differ. The NRL aren't that reliable; they still haven't fixed up the goal kicking mix-up from a couple of weeks ago, that I previously mentioned. This is your website, not mine, so you can do what you want. :)